Helicopter Parenting and Neurotic Kids

helicopterparentsToday, I read a fabulous article on MSNBC.  I am reposting it for your reading pleasure as it is not only interesting, but got my wheels turning about free-range parenting.   When I was growing up, when kids went off to college, it was not just for an educational experience, but more so a life experience.  Nowadays, parents don’t allow their children to grow and learn because of their over-protectiveness.  It has actually become a fault.  I know we live in different times now and the world has changed, but we have to allow our children to become independent because without independence they cannot flourish as adults.  It all starts before the age of 5.  Enjoy!

Helicopter Parents have Neurotic Kids
By:  Rachel Rettner

Overly protective parents might be leaving a lasting impact on their child’s personality, and not in a good way, a new study finds.

The results show having so-called “helicopter parents” was associated with being dependent, neurotic and less open, a slew of personality traits that are generally thought of as undesirable.

The study, which surveyed college freshman, is one of the first to try to define exactly what helicopter parenting is, and measure it. The term was originally coined by college admissions personnel when they started to notice a change in parents of prospective students – parents would call the admissions office and try to intervene in a process that had previously just been between the student and the college, said study researcher Neil Montgomery, a psychologist at Keene State College in New Hampshire.

While the findings are only preliminary, and more studies are needed to back up the results, they suggest this type of over-parenting might lead to children who are ultimately not ready to leave the nest.

“I think what the helicopter parents did is they decided, ‘OK we know what good parenting looks like, we’re just going to ratchet it up to a new level, and our kids are going to be even better,’” Montgomery said. “The problem is, when they ratcheted it up, they went too far, and in fact, caused an expansion of childhood or adolescence.”

Hovering parents, neurotic children
Montgomery and his colleagues surveyed about 300 freshmen with a questionnaire the researchers specifically designed to assess helicopter parenting. They focused on college students, because college is a “crisis point” in the relationship between the helicopter parent and the child, Montgomery said. At this stage, the parents no longer have control over their child’s life and can’t keep track of them like in the past.

Participants had to rate their level of agreement with statements such as, “My parents have contacted a school official on my behalf to solve problems for me,” “On my college move-in day, my parents stayed the night in town to make sure I was adjusted,” and “If two days go by without contact, my parents would contact me.”

About 10 percent of the participants had helicopter parents. The rate was higher in girls than in boys, with 13 percent of the females being helicoptered compared with just 5 percent of males. And it was mainly mothers doing the hovering, Montgomery said.

Students with helicopter parents tended to be less open to new ideas and actions, as well as more vulnerable, anxious and self-consciousness, among other factors, compared with their counterparts with more distant parents.

“We have a person who is dependent, who is vulnerable, who is self-conscious, who is anxious, who is impulsive, not open to new actions or ideas; is that going to make a successful college student?” Montgomery said. “No, not exactly, it’s really a horrible story at the end of the day.”

On the other hand, in non-helicoptered students who were given responsibility and not constantly monitored by their parents – so-called “free rangers” – the effects were reversed, Montgomery said.

Future outlook
Montgomery notes that the findings only show an association, and not a direct cause-effect link, meaning all children with helicopter parents don’t necessarily turn out this way. However, he thinks the research should encourage parents to think about what they are doing as they raise their children, and be aware that there is such a thing as over-parenting.

He hopes the work leads to more research in the area, including large studies on different populations of children, such as high-school and middle-school students. Future studies will hopefully bring about a clearer picture of helicopter parenting, Montgomery said.

“People keep talking about it like everyone knows what it is,” Montgomery said. “And it’s not clear that anyone really knows what it is, other than the people they know personally who are doing these things.”

The results were presented May 29 at the Association of Psychological Science Convention in Boston.

Peace & Blessings,
Di

Share

Overprotecting: How far is too far?

overprotectivemomAre you one of those parents that drives your son or daughter to the bus stop one block away from your house or you refuse to let them play outside due to your fear of the unknown?  Or, maybe you are one of those parents that goes way out of your way just to make your child’s life excessively easy.  In the November issue of Family Circle magazine, there is a fabulous article called “Mom Overboard” written by Gay Norton Edelman and Rosalind Wiseman.  The article really touched home with me.  I, myself, am guilty of driving my son to school every day (there is no bus because we are in the walking zone) because before he started Kindergarten, I googled the sex offenders in the area and found there were a few as I am sure there are in every neighborhood in the United States.My little boy is in the 5th grade now and has asked for a little independence and wants to walk to school with his friends. I have allowed him to walk home on occasion with a group, but this was a huge step for me.

The authors of the Family Circle article said it best, “it used to be simpler to be a mom.”  Can I get an Amen?  Life is much more complex, and unfortunately, some folks nowadays are just plain crazy so I guess you could say I might fall into the category of being a bit overprotective.  My philosophy has always been “it’s better to be safe than sorry.” I, like all parents, want to protect my children,  but I have noticed that when I give my little boy a chance to show that he can be a responsible 11 year old, I am rarely disappointed or have reason to get into full-blown overprotective mom mode.  I have found that most of the time he can do the things I seem to think he is too young to handle (i.e., walking home from school with a group of friends).  It is a matter of learning when to let go and let them be more independent. 

Further, the authors also discuss the issue of teens and tweens and how it is especially challenging today to parent them.  They say, “it used to be simpler to be a mom – you’d set boundaries and offer guidance, give your kids some space and get on with the rest of your life.  Today, not so much.  Now it seems like you’re expected to throw every ounce of your energy into running all aspects of your children’s lives.  With the advances in technology today (i.e., text messaging, cell phones, tweeting) the habit of overparenting has become easy.  According to Jean M. Twenge, Ph.D., research has shown that children who are overparented have an inflated sense of self.  They end up thinking they’re the center of the universe, being immature and not having good self-control.  Overinduldged kids are unprepared to deal with real life because they have not been allowed to practice fighting their own battles and rebounding solo from challenges.  What you end up with, Twenge says, are people who “lack empathy, have relationship problems and react aggressively when things don’t go the way they want.”

Another great point in the article the fact that a lot of parents allow perfectionism to get the best of them.  They set the bar too high for their children and they blur the line between their own ego and their child’s.  For example, they feel that their children’s failure at something is a direct reflection of their failure or disappointment.  In a nutshell, sometimes we have to let them take the “F” and learn the lesson.  The article goes on to say that parents can also get caught up in a vicious cycle of codependency.  For example, a mother devotes all her time and energy to her children and the more she does, the more they rely on her.  She then needs their feedback and everybody is locked into this cycle. 

One line in this article said it all for me.  “Above all, kids who have had more of what they want than what they need will be missing the key ingredient of true happiness.
Peace & Blessings,
Di
 
Share